Moderationpolicy - Historie editací

Een: /* Penalty grid */

2013-05-30T19:13:08Z

Penalty grid

← Starší verze		Verze z 30. 5. 2013, 21:13
Řádek 102:		Řádek 102:
	\| Inappropriate username		\| Inappropriate username
	\| If needed, report author should explain why this is inappropriate. Username are inappropriate when this is obviously an insult for many people. Moderators shouldn't moderate a username that is insulting by accident in a language that is not widely used on BGA.		\| If needed, report author should explain why this is inappropriate. Username are inappropriate when this is obviously an insult for many people. Moderators shouldn't moderate a username that is insulting by accident in a language that is not widely used on BGA.
	\| Ban from the website. Moderators should explain that the player is welcome with another username on BGA. Note that if the player has a long seniority on BGA (=many games played), moderators should be very cautious on the case: if no one ~~notice~~ the username until now, it is probably not inappropriate.		\| Ban from the website. Moderators should explain that the player is welcome with another username on BGA. Note that if the player has a long seniority on BGA (=many games played), moderators should be very cautious on the case: if no one noticed the username until now, it is probably not inappropriate.
	\|-		\|-
	! Table description		! Table description
Řádek 111:		Řádek 111:
	! Kingmaking		! Kingmaking
	\| Kingmaking action during a game		\| Kingmaking action during a game
	\| The report must contains the table id, the exact move number, and the exact explanation why this is a kingmaking action. To declare a player guilty, the player must have played an obvious move against his own interest, and it ~~have~~ to be a good player (clues: his ELO, number of game played, ...). As the difference between a mistake and a kingmaking action is very tight, one kingmaking report is not enough to find a player guilty: only players who regularly play against their interest should be found guilty.		\| The report must contains the table id, the exact move number, and the exact explanation why this is a kingmaking action. To declare a player guilty, the player must have played an obvious move against his own interest, and it has to be a good player (clues: his ELO, number of game played, ...). As the difference between a mistake and a kingmaking action is very tight, one kingmaking report is not enough to find a player guilty: only players who regularly play against their interest should be found guilty.
	\| -1 to -10 reputation penalty. Moderators should warn the player that this is a only small warning. Relapses can lead to higher reputation points penalties.		\| -1 to -10 reputation penalty. Moderators should warn the player that this is a only small warning. Relapses can lead to higher reputation points penalties.
	\|-		\|-
Řádek 121:		Řádek 121:
	! Private information		! Private information
	\| Some player gives some private information during the game		\| Some player gives some private information during the game
	\| Players have the right to pretend things during a game. As these infos could be true or false, and could be exploited by other players too, moderators should be cautious when judging these cases. This case concerns players that had a strong ~~voluntee~~ to kill the pleasure of the game by giving some private information during the game.		\| Players have the right to pretend things during a game. As these infos could be true or false, and could be exploited by other players too, moderators should be cautious when judging these cases. This case concerns players that had a strong intent to kill the pleasure of the game by giving some private information during the game.
	\| -1 to -10 reputation penalty. Moderators should warn the player that this is a only small warning. Relapses can lead to higher reputation points penalties.		\| -1 to -10 reputation penalty. Moderators should warn the player that this is a only small warning. Relapses can lead to higher reputation points penalties.
	\|-		\|-
	! Multiple accounts		! Multiple accounts
	\| A player is using multiple accounts (most of the time: to boost his ELO rank)		\| A player is using multiple accounts (most of the time: to boost his ELO rank)
	\| The report must contains the usernames of all intimidated accounts, and the reason why the report author think that multiple accounts are used. ~~This~~ is very difficult to find out if different accounts corresponds to different person. For example: BGA accepts that multiple players plays from the same IP ~~adress~~, to allow people from the same family to play at the same table. In addition, some players are using multiple accounts, but these accounts are not playing together (which is acceptable). Strong tools are available for moderators to detect multiple accounts that are used the wrong way.		\| The report must contains the usernames of all intimidated accounts, and the reason why the report author think that multiple accounts are used. It is very difficult to find out if different accounts corresponds to different person. For example: BGA accepts that multiple players plays from the same IP address, to allow people from the same family to play at the same table. In addition, some players are using multiple accounts, but these accounts are not playing together (which is acceptable). Strong tools are available for moderators to detect multiple accounts that are used the wrong way.
	\| For secondary accounts: ban forever. For main account: ELO reseted to 1500 / ELO penalty for all games.		\| For secondary accounts: ban forever. For main account: ELO reseted to 1500 / ELO penalty for all games.
	\|-		\|-
	! Something else		! Something else
	\| ~~Tranlation~~ stealing / vandalism		\| Translation stealing / vandalism
	\| The player is writing ~~inapropriate~~ / poor quality translations (or writes a lot of very minor modifications to someone else translation) to gain free club membership,		\| The player is writing inappropriate / poor quality translations (or writes a lot of very minor modifications to someone else translation) to gain free club membership,
	\| Immediate ban from the website (to avoid vandalism).		\| Immediate ban from the website (to avoid vandalism).
	\|-		\|-
	! Something else		! Something else
	\| Player is slow to play		\| Player is slow to play
	\| Players have the right to think as long as they do not go over their ~~alloted~~ time. If the player is slow on purpose, the good answer is: thumb down.		\| Players have the right to think as long as they do not go over their allotted time. If the player is slow on purpose, the good answer is: thumb down.
	\| No penalty		\| No penalty
	\|-		\|-

Een: /* Player profile influence */

2013-05-30T18:52:46Z

Player profile influence

← Starší verze		Verze z 30. 5. 2013, 20:52
Řádek 53:		Řádek 53:
	Good profile elements are:		Good profile elements are:
	* A good thumb up / thumb down ratio.		* A good thumb up / thumb down ratio.
	* Player is registered since a long time / has a lot of games ~~player~~.		* Player is registered since a long time / has a lot of games played.
	* Players is involved in the website (ex: realized translations).		* Players is involved in the website (ex: realized translations).
	* Player is supporting BGA (member of the club).		* Player is supporting BGA (member of the club).

Een: /* Player profile influence */

2013-05-30T18:52:15Z

Player profile influence

← Starší verze		Verze z 30. 5. 2013, 20:52
Řádek 47:		Řádek 47:
	=== Player profile influence ===		=== Player profile influence ===

	The player profile IS taken into account to determine if the player is guilty or not guilty. Moderators ~~gives~~ more credit to players with a good profile than the other.		The player profile IS taken into account to determine if the player is guilty or not guilty. Moderators give more credit to players with a good profile than the other.

	The player profile is NOT taken into account when choosing the penalty if the player is found guilty.		The player profile is NOT taken into account when choosing the penalty if the player is found guilty.

Een: /* Penalty grid */

2013-05-30T18:44:44Z

Penalty grid

← Starší verze		Verze z 30. 5. 2013, 20:44
Řádek 19:		Řádek 19:

	Moderators should respect the penalties grid as much as possible. However, they have the right to adjust the penalty depending on the gravity of the case. The following situation can lead moderators to increase the penalties:		Moderators should respect the penalties grid as much as possible. However, they have the right to adjust the penalty depending on the gravity of the case. The following situation can lead moderators to increase the penalties:
	* the player has been reported several ~~time~~ for the same type of case.		* the player has been reported several times for the same type of case.
	* the player wrong action can be obviously qualified by one or several of the following terms: racism, xenophobia, homophobia, sexism, and as a rule of thumb any type of discrimination against a particular category of people.		* the player wrong action can be obviously qualified by one or several of the following terms: racism, xenophobia, homophobia, sexism, and as a rule of thumb any type of discrimination against a particular category of people.
	* on case there is a provocation, the penalty may be be reduced a little, and the author of the provocation may have a warning BUT, as everyone should keep quiet and polite even if there are provoked, this is a moderator choice.		* on case there is a provocation, the penalty may be be reduced a little, and the author of the provocation may have a warning BUT, as everyone should keep quiet and polite even if there are provoked, this is a moderator choice.

Een: /* Penalty grid */

2013-05-30T18:44:30Z

Penalty grid

← Starší verze		Verze z 30. 5. 2013, 20:44
Řádek 19:		Řádek 19:

	Moderators should respect the penalties grid as much as possible. However, they have the right to adjust the penalty depending on the gravity of the case. The following situation can lead moderators to increase the penalties:		Moderators should respect the penalties grid as much as possible. However, they have the right to adjust the penalty depending on the gravity of the case. The following situation can lead moderators to increase the penalties:
	_ the player has been reported several time for the same type of case.		* the player has been reported several time for the same type of case.
	_ the player wrong action can be obviously qualified by one or several of the following terms: racism, xenophobia, homophobia, sexism, and as a rule of thumb any type of discrimination against a particular category of people.		* the player wrong action can be obviously qualified by one or several of the following terms: racism, xenophobia, homophobia, sexism, and as a rule of thumb any type of discrimination against a particular category of people.
	_ on case there is a provocation, the penalty may be be reduced a little, and the author of the provocation may have a warning BUT, as everyone should keep quiet and polite even if there are provoked, this is a moderator choice.		* on case there is a provocation, the penalty may be be reduced a little, and the author of the provocation may have a warning BUT, as everyone should keep quiet and polite even if there are provoked, this is a moderator choice.

	=== Relapse ===		=== Relapse ===

Sourisdudesert: /* Penalty grid */

2013-05-30T10:39:38Z

Penalty grid

← Starší verze		Verze z 30. 5. 2013, 12:39
Řádek 129:		Řádek 129:
	\| For secondary accounts: ban forever. For main account: ELO reseted to 1500 / ELO penalty for all games.		\| For secondary accounts: ban forever. For main account: ELO reseted to 1500 / ELO penalty for all games.
	\|-		\|-
	! ~~Donnée 1A~~		! Something else
	\| ~~Donnée 3A~~		\| Tranlation stealing / vandalism
	\| ~~Donnée 3B~~		\| The player is writing inapropriate / poor quality translations (or writes a lot of very minor modifications to someone else translation) to gain free club membership,
	\| ~~Donnée 3C~~		\| Immediate ban from the website (to avoid vandalism).
	\|-		\|-
	! ~~Donnée 1A~~		! Something else
	\| ~~Donnée 3A~~		\| Player is slow to play
	\| ~~Donnée 3B~~		\| Players have the right to think as long as they do not go over their alloted time. If the player is slow on purpose, the good answer is: thumb down.
	\| ~~Donnée 3C~~		\| No penalty
			\|-
			! Something else
			\| Player quit the game before the end
			\| In this case, player automatically gets a ELO penalty + a red mark on his profile. There is no need to do something else.
			\| No penalty
	\|-		\|-

	\|}		\|}

Sourisdudesert: /* Penalty grid */

2013-05-30T10:34:18Z

Penalty grid

← Starší verze		Verze z 30. 5. 2013, 12:34
Řádek 122:		Řádek 122:
	\| Some player gives some private information during the game		\| Some player gives some private information during the game
	\| Players have the right to pretend things during a game. As these infos could be true or false, and could be exploited by other players too, moderators should be cautious when judging these cases. This case concerns players that had a strong voluntee to kill the pleasure of the game by giving some private information during the game.		\| Players have the right to pretend things during a game. As these infos could be true or false, and could be exploited by other players too, moderators should be cautious when judging these cases. This case concerns players that had a strong voluntee to kill the pleasure of the game by giving some private information during the game.
	\| ~~Donnée 3C~~		\| -1 to -10 reputation penalty. Moderators should warn the player that this is a only small warning. Relapses can lead to higher reputation points penalties.
	\|-		\|-
	! ~~Donnée 1A~~		! Multiple accounts
	\| ~~Donnée 3A~~		\| A player is using multiple accounts (most of the time: to boost his ELO rank)
	\| ~~Donnée 3B~~		\| The report must contains the usernames of all intimidated accounts, and the reason why the report author think that multiple accounts are used. This is very difficult to find out if different accounts corresponds to different person. For example: BGA accepts that multiple players plays from the same IP adress, to allow people from the same family to play at the same table. In addition, some players are using multiple accounts, but these accounts are not playing together (which is acceptable). Strong tools are available for moderators to detect multiple accounts that are used the wrong way.
	\| ~~Donnée 3C~~		\| For secondary accounts: ban forever. For main account: ELO reseted to 1500 / ELO penalty for all games.
	\|-		\|-
	! Donnée 1A		! Donnée 1A

Sourisdudesert: /* Penalty grid */

2013-05-30T10:25:54Z

Penalty grid

← Starší verze		Verze z 30. 5. 2013, 12:25
Řádek 119:		Řádek 119:
	\| No penalty applies: if there is a bug that has been widely used for a game, a global ELO reset (or an ELO adjustment for players who exploited the bug) will be done.		\| No penalty applies: if there is a bug that has been widely used for a game, a global ELO reset (or an ELO adjustment for players who exploited the bug) will be done.
	\|-		\|-
	! ~~Donnée 1A~~		! Private information
	\| ~~Donnée 3A~~		\| Some player gives some private information during the game
	\| ~~Donnée 3B~~		\| Players have the right to pretend things during a game. As these infos could be true or false, and could be exploited by other players too, moderators should be cautious when judging these cases. This case concerns players that had a strong voluntee to kill the pleasure of the game by giving some private information during the game.
	\| Donnée 3C		\| Donnée 3C
	\|-		\|-

Sourisdudesert: /* Penalty grid */

2013-05-30T10:21:14Z

Penalty grid

← Starší verze		Verze z 30. 5. 2013, 12:21
Řádek 117:		Řádek 117:
	\| Exploit a known bug during a game		\| Exploit a known bug during a game
	\| The bug must have been reported in the forum, and an exact reference to this bug must be in the report, with the table id and the move number. Minor bugs that can be considered as "variants" are NOT concerned (ex: pick 4 cards instead of 3). Bugs that violate the spirit of the game are concerned.		\| The bug must have been reported in the forum, and an exact reference to this bug must be in the report, with the table id and the move number. Minor bugs that can be considered as "variants" are NOT concerned (ex: pick 4 cards instead of 3). Bugs that violate the spirit of the game are concerned.
	\| No penalty applies: if there is a bug that has been widely used for a game, a global ELO reset will be done.		\| No penalty applies: if there is a bug that has been widely used for a game, a global ELO reset (or an ELO adjustment for players who exploited the bug) will be done.
	\|-		\|-
	! Donnée 1A		! Donnée 1A

Sourisdudesert: /* Penalty grid */

2013-05-30T10:20:40Z

Penalty grid

← Starší verze		Verze z 30. 5. 2013, 12:20
Řádek 112:		Řádek 112:
	\| Kingmaking action during a game		\| Kingmaking action during a game
	\| The report must contains the table id, the exact move number, and the exact explanation why this is a kingmaking action. To declare a player guilty, the player must have played an obvious move against his own interest, and it have to be a good player (clues: his ELO, number of game played, ...). As the difference between a mistake and a kingmaking action is very tight, one kingmaking report is not enough to find a player guilty: only players who regularly play against their interest should be found guilty.		\| The report must contains the table id, the exact move number, and the exact explanation why this is a kingmaking action. To declare a player guilty, the player must have played an obvious move against his own interest, and it have to be a good player (clues: his ELO, number of game played, ...). As the difference between a mistake and a kingmaking action is very tight, one kingmaking report is not enough to find a player guilty: only players who regularly play against their interest should be found guilty.
	\| -1 to -10 reputation penalty. Moderators should warn the player that this is a only small warning.		\| -1 to -10 reputation penalty. Moderators should warn the player that this is a only small warning. Relapses can lead to higher reputation points penalties.
	\|-		\|-
	! ~~Donnée 1A~~		! Bug exploit
	\| ~~Donnée 3A~~		\| Exploit a known bug during a game
	\| ~~Donnée 3B~~		\| The bug must have been reported in the forum, and an exact reference to this bug must be in the report, with the table id and the move number. Minor bugs that can be considered as "variants" are NOT concerned (ex: pick 4 cards instead of 3). Bugs that violate the spirit of the game are concerned.
	\| ~~Donnée 3C~~		\| No penalty applies: if there is a bug that has been widely used for a game, a global ELO reset will be done.
	\|-		\|-
	! Donnée 1A		! Donnée 1A